Showing posts with label Bersih. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bersih. Show all posts

Monday, October 10, 2011

Bersih: Police corporal ‘scapegoat’ in Tung Shin scandal

If this article is true.....just when I am starting to believe that change is imminent...then we read about this. Maybe we are too foolish to believe the media reporting...again? Why can't we try to get simple things right instead of covering up? When we do this too many times, we will lose track of truths, half truths and lies. Is this how we want to pass the baton to our next generation?

Until the next time, cheers.

The Malaysian Insider, Sunday, 9 October 2011

Bersih: Police corporal ‘scapegoat’ in Tung Shin scandal


Bersih steering committee member Maria Chin Abdullah said that pinpointing one scapegoat is not going to give the public any confidence that any investigation is going to be fair. — file pic
KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 9 — Bersih 2.0 said today authorities have made a scapegoat of the policeman held solely responsible for firing tear gas into Tung Shin Hospital during the July 9 rally for free and fair elections.
 
“This is ridiculous. Everyone saw ... the whole world saw the video. The poor guy is the scapegoat.

“If you say just one, did they really do a proper investigation? How can they say it’s one?” Bersih steering committee member Maria Chin Abdullah told The Malaysian Insider.
Kuala Lumpur police had said yesterday that the police corporal who breached standard operating procedure (SOP) during the rally would be disciplined.

“Just like the minister of health (Datuk Seri Liow Tiong Lai) who denied Tung Shin was attacked by police, this is a denial that more than one police officer was involved,” Chin added.

In a report made public on Tuesday, the Health Ministry had determined that police acted in an unethical manner and breached SOP when dispersing demonstrators who had converged on the hospital to escape riot police.

The report prompted a statement from Home Ministry secretary-general Tan Sri Mahmood Adam that the matter would be referred to the police disciplinary committee.

“If you deal with abuse in this manner, having one scapegoat is not going to give the public any confidence that any investigation is going to be fair,” Chin said.

Police had absolved themselves of any wrongdoing during the July 9 rally after setting up six internal teams to investigate claims of police brutality that followed after nearly 1,700 were arrested, scores injured and an ex-soldier died during chaotic scenes in the capital.

But Health Minister Datuk Seri Liow Tiong Lai ordered a second probe into the Tung Shin incident on July 14 after a group of medical consultants had written to the media refuting the hospital board and police who claimed that no gas canisters or water cannons were fired into the hospital.

Police finally admitted on July 21 that Tung Shin was hit with tear gas canisters and water cannon during the rally, but denied shooting directly into the compound.

But this claim flies in the face of various video clips uploaded on the YouTube video-sharing site showing water cannon and tear gas being fired into the hospital area.

Sunday, July 10, 2011

The day after Bersih........

Well, yesterday's Bersih rally was a significant day for a lot of Malaysians whether they took part or not. Although there were 50,000 (depending who was counting) who took part, there were a lot more who wished they were there.

One thing for sure, the frustration with the Government and the police is surely growing. Personally, I feel the Najib administration as with his earlier predecessor, PM Abdullah Badawi has made the biggest error of trying to portray the cause of Bersih as bad for the country and economy.

For me, the crux of the matter is how do we want to treat our own people. Do we want to pull the wool over their eyes and think them as fools (like how the Govt owned media is trying to do) or to think Malaysians are a bunch of trouble makers (like how the police as decided before the rally) or Malaysians are a bunch that can be bullied or threatened (like how the the Govt and police are using their authority)?

Please do not do that, it is a dead end. If only, the BN started to change this mindset, I am sure a lot of middle Malaysia will go back to support them (both Malays and non-Malays). I just cannot figure what why they would want to take self destructive steps.
BN should also understand that a lot of Malaysians do not just support the opposition but are doing so because they are upset with BN. There is a huge difference! This is more so pertinent when as the incumbent, you have so much power to do good and yet only give lip service. I myself, am frustrated by this.

For the media, the old strategy of spinning is so outdated that I find it so amusing that they think they can actually get away with it. Maybe the people working there know it but their political masters are not willing to accept it? Sometimes, they themselves spinned so much that they actually get lost themselves. In addition, they are suddenly so fair and independent when analysing about other countries political situation and yet so biased in their local analysis.

For the opposition, the same criteria will be put on them if they are elected. There are no favoritism when it comes to the welfare of the country and people. For me, the opposition parties are also full of opportunists and clowns. So, we must move away from party politics and choose the right candidate who works hard for the people and country and with the right consciense.

In today newspaper, I had some good laughs at the statement by our IGP as well as some of the articles and columns in The Star. Their articles only look at one side only so how can we call it fair? 

I was touched to see so many people from all walks of life who braved danger to walk for their believe and cause. If so many young people in Malaysia have such strong believes and are willing to fight for them (peacefully), then I can say Malaysia will have a good future.

Until the next time, cheers.

Friday, July 8, 2011

Yellow: What’s behind the shade? - The Star columnist writes

In the Along the watchtower column in The Star, I read with much amusement what the writer wanted to convey. I was unsure whether it was his attempt at being humorous or trying to subtly trying to brainwash us on the color yellow or as an educational article (lots of interesting facts) or even as a all out spin, I don't know. Maybe it was written in a half hearted manner? What do to, all of us have to "cari makan" what.

Anyhow, the article is as below for your own judgement.

Until the next time, cheers.

The Star, Thursday, 6 July 2011

Along The Watchtower
By M. Veera Pandiyan

The organisers of Bersih 2.0 should explain their links and funding by the NED.
 
IT’S been a rather eventful week shaded by the overwhelming colour of yellow.

In psychology, the colour is associated with optimism and cheerfulness.

Yellow, the colour of the sun, is linked with laughter, happiness and good times.

People surrounded by yellow feel optimistic because the brain actually releases more serotonin, the happy hormone that influences mood and sense of well-being.

But yellow can also be quickly overpowering if over-used. When intense, it can inflame and also evoke fear.

Studies show that babies cry more in bright yellow rooms and adults are more likely to lose their tempers in such places.

Apparently, energy levels can be taken up by the intensity of the colour to the point of it becoming an irritant.

Primarily, yellow is used to attract attention.

That is why most danger signs come in yellow and black.

Spiritually, the hue is said to provide clarity of thought and enlightenment of mood.

Yellow has a very colourful use in language. The terms “yellow belly” or “yellow streak” connote it with cowardice, deceit or betrayal.

During the Middle Ages, paintings by Christian artists depicted Judas by dressing him in yellow.

In China, a pornographic film is called “yellow movie”, unlike the “blue movie” used in the west and elsewhere.

In Arab culture, people can recognise a “yellow smile” – a fake expression.

Such smiles are put on when people want to hide their lack of interest, or any other emotion.

It is similar to the French expression of rire jaune (yellow laughter), which means to laugh from the wrong side of the mouth or feigned mirth.

Politically, yellow characterises freedom and moderation in many countries.

In the US, where yellow traditionally has a negative nuance, the Gadsden Flag, a symbol of American independence, has become popular again, especially with “Tea Party” activists.

The yellow flag, with a fierce-looking rattlesnake, coiled and ready to strike, bears the motto: “Don’t Tread on Me”.

The US is also the origin of “yellow journalism” – the phrase to describe irresponsible, exaggerated, lurid and slanderous reporting that can be traced to the late 1800s when two newspaper owners tried to outdo each other with their front-page stories to get the highest circulation.

Joseph Pulitzer (yes, of the Pulitzer Prize fame) who owned the New York World was the first to make use of sensational journalism to impress readers.

For example, his headline for a story on a heat wave that killed many people was: “How Babies are Baked”.

His rival, William Randolph Hearst, who owned the San Francisco Examiner, bought the New York Journal and also bought over Pulitzer’s top writers to outdo the World.

The rivalry was most intense before the Spanish-American War, when both papers churned out outrageous headlines to whip up support for the US, much to the dismay of other publishers and editors.

Both papers were denounced as “yellow journals”, inferring that Pulitzer and Hearst were cowards who chose the easy way to gain readers through sensationalisation and false news rather than responsible reporting.

Back home in Malaysia, critics of the mainstream media have been accused of being “yellow-bellied”, especially with regard to positions taken on the Bersih 2.0 rally.

The organisers of our yellow rally have since agreed to call it off and hold their gathering in a stadium instead after an audience with the Yang di-Pertuan Agong.

If Bersih 2.0 is indeed all about the noble cause of demanding free and fair elections, it must be rightly given the utmost support by all Malaysians.

The organisers of Bersih 2.0, however, must also explain their association and funding by the US’ National Endowment for Democracy (NED).

Even in the US, many questions are being asked about the NED set up in the early 1980s in the wake of negative revelations about the CIA.

According to William Blum the writer of Killing Hope: US Military and CIA Interventions Since World War II, the NED was set up to overtly do what the CIA had been doing covertly for decades.

He described it as a “masterpiece of politics, public relations and cynicism”.

Ron Paul, a Republican Congressman from Texas, described the NED as “nothing more than a costly programme that takes US taxpayer funds to promote favoured politicians and political parties abroad”.

“What the NED does in foreign countries, through its recipient organisations the National Demo­cratic Institute and the International Republican Institute, would be rightly illegal in the US.

“The NED injects soft money into the domestic elections of foreign countries in favour of one party or the other.

“It is particularly Orwellian to call US manipulation of foreign elections ‘promoting democracy.’

With such questions, don’t Malaysians deserve to know more about links between Bersih 2.0 and other Malaysian NGOs funded by the NED?

> Associate Editor M. Veera Pandiyan likes Coldplay’s song “Yellow”.

Running scared in Malaysia by John Malott in The WSJ

Mr Mallott was the Malaysian Ambassador to Malaysia some time ago. Ever since he left Malaysia, he has been quite critical of the Government in areas of human rights and political fairness. In another article that appeared in The Malaysian Chronicle, he words were much more stronger and colorful than in this article. From what I read, he has some strong views the way we conduct business here. Maybe, he has more information or intelligence than most of us, Malaysians.

Running scared in Malaysia by John Malott in The WSJ

The Malaysian government has pulled out all the stops to prevent an opposition rally this weekend. This week, army units conducted crowd control exercises with banners that said, "Disperse or we will shoot!" 

By John Malott, The Wall Street Journal  



The police set up roadblocks and arrested Malaysians simply for wearing yellow T-shirts, the signature color of Bersih, a coalition of 62 nongovernmental organizations that demands changes in Malaysia's electoral system. To date, the police have arrested over 250 supporters of Bersih, claiming that they are "waging war against the king."

Then something unprecedented happened. Malaysia's King Tuanku Mizan Zainal Abidin, allegedly the target of Bersih's campaign, intervened. He called on both Prime Minister Najib Razak and Bersih to resolve their differences in a spirit of harmony and cooperation, for the good of the nation.

There was a collective sigh of relief in Malaysia. The leader of Bersih, Ambiga Sreenevasan, an attorney and former president of the Malaysian Bar Council, met with the king and announced that the "Walk for Democracy," as it was called, was cancelled. She said that she was ready to meet with the government to discuss Bersih's concerns about electoral fairness. Prime Minister Najib then offered an olive branch, saying, "We are willing to provide a stadium for them to rally in … from morning until night," an offer that Ms. Ambiga and Bersih immediately accepted.

Then Mr. Najib backed off. His government says that because Bersih is still illegal, it cannot apply for a permit. It also has banned Bersih's leadership from entering Kuala Lumpur on the day of the rally. On Thursday, he joined a gathering of martial artists who said that their 50,000 members will "wage war" against Bersih. Donning their militant uniform, Mr. Najib said, "If there are evil enemies who want to attack the country from within, you, my brothers, will rise to fight them."

Mr. Najib has undermined the authority of the king, who gave Bersih and its concerns credence by meeting with its leadership and calling for a negotiated solution. The political situation in Malaysia is a fast-moving target, and each day brings new developments. Ms. Ambiga and Bersih now say that because of Mr. Najib's actions, they will go ahead with their assembly, no matter what.

Nobody knows what will happen tomorrow. Bersih's main issue is not freedom of assembly but the fairness of Malaysia's democratic process. Bersih's backers ask how anyone can be opposed to free and fair elections.

It's an easy question to answer. The United Malays National Organization, of which Mr. Najib is president, is the longest continuing ruling party in the world, and it is running scared.

In the last general election in 2008, Malaysia's opposition took 47% of the popular vote. That year Parti Keadilan Rakyat, the party of Mr. Najib's nemesis Anwar Ibrahim, went from one seat to 31. The establishment parties in Malaysia's neighboring states are also in retreat. The opposition scored a major victory in Thailand last weekend, and in Singapore opposition candidates made surprising gains. No wonder Mr. Najib and company are worried.

Many observers of Malaysian politics believe that electoral reform will lead to the ruling party's defeat, and that is why UMNO is afraid of Bersih. In the last election in 2008, the party received only one-third of the nation's votes. UMNO rules only because of its coalition with other political parties, which it increasingly marginalizes, that represent the Chinese and Indian minorities.

Mr. Najib and his allies say that the opposition's gains in 2008 prove that Malaysia's elections are free and fair. Impartial observers disagree. Academic studies have enumerated how the Election Commission gerrymanders electoral districts to benefit the ruling party. The U.S. Department of State's human rights report bluntly states that opposition parties are unable to compete on equal terms with the governing coalition because of restrictions on campaigning and freedom of assembly and association. "News of the opposition," the U.S. says, is "tightly restricted and reported in a biased fashion."

In the recent state elections in Sarawak, the government announced $390 million in local projects during the run-up to the polls. Prime Minister Najib was caught on video tape telling one village gathering that the government would give them 5 million ringgit ($1.5 million) for a local project on Monday, but only if they elected his candidate on Sunday.

Who would win elections in Malaysia that truly are free and fair? The U.S. State Department reports that despite the many election irregularities during the 2008 elections, "most observers concluded they did not substantially alter the results." But unless the electoral reforms that Bersih is calling for are made, we will never know.

Despite the government's intimidation, thousands of Malaysian citizens of all races and religions are expected to exercise their constitutional right to assemble and call for free and fair elections. Tomorrow's protest represents a brave step in what not just Malaysians but also the international community should hope will begin the country's transition to full democracy. Mr. Najib should display his own courage and ensure that a peaceful rally that seeks the fundamental rights of democratic peoples everywhere does not turn into a bloody confrontation.

Mr. Malott was the United States ambassador to Malaysia from 1995-98.